| ➡️AJ Styles (4) | 4 Events | 2 Match Types | | 2 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Adam Bomb (2) | 2 Events | 2 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Alberto Del Rio (3) | 3 Events | 2 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Andre the Giant (20) | 20 Events | 11 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 5 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Animal (10) | 10 Events | 5 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Ax (5) | 5 Events | 4 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Bam Bam Bigelow (11) | 11 Events | 4 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️Barbarian (4) | 4 Events | 2 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Batista (2) | 2 Events | 2 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Batman (16) | 16 Events | 7 Match Types | | 4 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Berzerker (3) | 3 Events | 2 Match Types | | | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Big Boss Man (24) | 24 Events | 10 Match Types | | 5 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | 1 Elimination |
| ➡️Big E (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Big Show (6) | 6 Events | 3 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Bill (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Billy (2) | 2 Events | 2 Match Types | | 2 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Billy Gunn (2) | 2 Events | 2 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | | | |
| ➡️Billy Kidman (7) | 7 Events | 4 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️Black (11) | 11 Events | 5 Match Types | | 4 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | 1 Elimination |
| ➡️Bo Dallas (2) | 2 Events | 2 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️Bob Backlund (3) | 3 Events | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Bobby Heenan (7) | 7 Events | 5 Match Types | | 3 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Boogeyman (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Booker T (8) | 8 Events | 4 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️Boss (10) | 10 Events | 5 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 2 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | 1 Elimination |
| ➡️Bray Wyatt (5) | 5 Events | 3 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Bret Hart (58) | 58 Events | 19 Match Types | 3 Shared Teams | 15 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 3 Eliminations | 3 Eliminations |
| ➡️Brian Kendrick (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Brian Knobbs (7) | 7 Events | 4 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️British Bulldog (19) | 19 Events | 8 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 6 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Brock Lesnar (10) | 10 Events | 4 Match Types | | 4 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | 1 Elimination |
| ➡️Brodus Clay (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Brutus Beefcake (5) | 5 Events | 3 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | | | |
| ➡️Bubba Ray Dudley (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Buff Bagwell (2) | 2 Events | 2 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Butch (4) | 4 Events | 3 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | | | |
| ➡️CM Punk (12) | 12 Events | 10 Match Types | | 5 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Carlito (2) | 2 Events | 1 Match Type | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Cesaro (4) | 4 Events | 2 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | | | |
| ➡️Chris Jericho (27) | 27 Events | 11 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 8 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 2 Eliminations | |
| ➡️Christian Cage (17) | 17 Events | 12 Match Types | | 7 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | 1 Elimination |
| ➡️Chyna (4) | 4 Events | 3 Match Types | 2 Shared Teams | | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Cody Rhodes (8) | 8 Events | 5 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 2 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Crush (12) | 12 Events | 6 Match Types | | 4 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Curt Hennig (23) | 23 Events | 8 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 7 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 2 Eliminations | |
| ➡️D-Von Dudley (4) | 4 Events | 4 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️DDP (2) | 2 Events | 1 Match Type | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️DH Smith (5) | 5 Events | 4 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Damien Sandow (2) | 2 Events | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Daniel Bryan (4) | 4 Events | 3 Match Types | | | | 1 Elimination |
| ➡️Darren Young (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Dean Ambrose (3) | 3 Events | 2 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️Doink (7) | 7 Events | 5 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Dolph Ziggler (2) | 2 Events | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Dusty Rhodes (3) | 3 Events | 2 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Earthquake (5) | 5 Events | 3 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️Eddie Guerrero (10) | 10 Events | 6 Match Types | | 2 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Edge (12) | 12 Events | 9 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 5 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | 2 Eliminations |
| ➡️Egon Spengler (4) | 4 Events | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Erick Rowan (2) | 2 Events | 2 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️Eugene (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Evan Bourne (3) | 3 Events | 2 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Fandango (2) | 2 Events | 2 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️Finn Balor (2) | 2 Events | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Forester (24) | 24 Events | 12 Match Types | 2 Shared Teams | 6 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | 1 Elimination |
| ➡️Funaki (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️GI Joe (9) | 9 Events | 6 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Gene Okerlund (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Giant Gonzales (2) | 2 Events | 2 Match Types | | | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Goldberg (15) | 15 Events | 9 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 4 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Goldust (13) | 13 Events | 6 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 4 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Gorilla Monsoon (3) | 3 Events | 3 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 2 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Greg Valentine (7) | 7 Events | 3 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️Harley Race (2) | 2 Events | 2 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️Hawk (9) | 9 Events | 5 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Homicide (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Honky Tonk Man (10) | 10 Events | 3 Match Types | | 2 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Hulk Hogan (28) | 28 Events | 13 Match Types | 2 Shared Teams | 8 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️IRS (6) | 6 Events | 4 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Iron Sheik (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️JBL (3) | 3 Events | 3 Match Types | | | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Jack Swagger (6) | 6 Events | 4 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Jake Roberts (32) | 32 Events | 11 Match Types | 2 Shared Teams | 13 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 2 Eliminations | |
| ➡️Jason (22) | 22 Events | 12 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 6 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | 2 Eliminations |
| ➡️Jay Lethal (2) | 2 Events | 2 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Jeff Hardy (11) | 11 Events | 6 Match Types | | 2 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Jeff Jarrett (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Jerry Lawler (4) | 4 Events | 3 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Jerry Sags (9) | 9 Events | 4 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Jim Duggan (6) | 6 Events | 5 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Jim Neidhart (10) | 10 Events | 5 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | 2 Eliminations | |
| ➡️Jimmy Snuka (6) | 6 Events | 3 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️John Cena (6) | 6 Events | 6 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 3 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️John Morrison (7) | 7 Events | 3 Match Types | | 4 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Justin Gabriel (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Kamala (2) | 2 Events | 1 Match Type | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Kane (20) | 20 Events | 10 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 4 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 2 Eliminations | |
| ➡️Karl Hennig (8) | 8 Events | 3 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Ken Shamrock (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Kevin Nash (27) | 27 Events | 13 Match Types | 4 Shared Teams | 7 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Kevin Owens (2) | 2 Events | 2 Match Types | | | | 1 Elimination |
| ➡️Kofi Kingston (3) | 3 Events | 2 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️Koko B Ware (3) | 3 Events | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Kris Kanyon (6) | 6 Events | 4 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Kurt Angle (18) | 18 Events | 9 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 4 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Lex Luger (2) | 2 Events | 2 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️Luke (4) | 4 Events | 3 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | | | |
| ➡️Luke Harper (2) | 2 Events | 2 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️Mark Henry (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Marty Jannetty (26) | 26 Events | 6 Match Types | 5 Shared Teams | 3 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | 1 Elimination |
| ➡️Matt Hardy (12) | 12 Events | 7 Match Types | | 2 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Mick Foley (15) | 15 Events | 6 Match Types | | 4 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Mike Awesome (3) | 3 Events | 2 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️Mountie (2) | 2 Events | 2 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️Mr Hardcore (13) | 13 Events | 4 Match Types | | 2 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | 1 Elimination |
| ➡️Mysterious Mark (6) | 6 Events | 3 Match Types | | 2 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Natalya (4) | 4 Events | 3 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️Neville (3) | 3 Events | 2 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️Nikolai Volkoff (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Octoman (3) | 3 Events | 2 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️Official (3) | 3 Events | 2 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️One Man Gang (18) | 18 Events | 8 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 4 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Orlando Jordan (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Owen Hart (17) | 17 Events | 7 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 2 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Paige (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Papa Shango (9) | 9 Events | 4 Match Types | | 2 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Paul London (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Peter Venkman (2) | 2 Events | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Quantum (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️R-Truth (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Randy Orton (16) | 16 Events | 9 Match Types | | 4 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Randy Savage (29) | 29 Events | 12 Match Types | | 7 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | 1 Elimination |
| ➡️Reebot (16) | 16 Events | 8 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 5 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 2 Eliminations | |
| ➡️Rey Mysterio (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Ric Flair (25) | 25 Events | 12 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 4 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Ricardo Rodriguez (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Rick Martel (19) | 19 Events | 6 Match Types | | 4 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Rick Rude (4) | 4 Events | 3 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | | | |
| ➡️Rick Steiner (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Ricky Steamboat (3) | 3 Events | 2 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Ricochet (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Rikishi (14) | 14 Events | 7 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 3 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Road Dogg (2) | 2 Events | 2 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | | | |
| ➡️Rob Van Dam (3) | 3 Events | 2 Match Types | | 2 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Roddy Piper (10) | 10 Events | 4 Match Types | | 2 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Roman Reigns (4) | 4 Events | 3 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Rusev (4) | 4 Events | 3 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Ryback (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Sami Zayn (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Samoa Joe (7) | 7 Events | 5 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Samu (3) | 3 Events | 2 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Scott Hall (31) | 31 Events | 15 Match Types | 3 Shared Teams | 10 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 2 Eliminations | |
| ➡️Scott Steiner (12) | 12 Events | 6 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Sensational Sherri (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Seth Rollins (3) | 3 Events | 2 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️Sgt Slaughter (10) | 10 Events | 4 Match Types | | 3 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Shane McMahon (3) | 3 Events | 2 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Sheamus (4) | 4 Events | 4 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Shelton Benjamin (4) | 4 Events | 2 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Sid Vicious (23) | 23 Events | 6 Match Types | 2 Shared Teams | 10 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Sin Cara (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Skinner (2) | 2 Events | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Smash (10) | 10 Events | 4 Match Types | | 3 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Spiderman (4) | 4 Events | 1 Match Type | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Steve Austin (26) | 26 Events | 14 Match Types | | 8 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 2 Eliminations | |
| ➡️Sting (18) | 18 Events | 9 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 3 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 2 Eliminations | 1 Elimination |
| ➡️Storm (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Tatanka (5) | 5 Events | 3 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Tazz (2) | 2 Events | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Ted DiBiase (15) | 15 Events | 6 Match Types | | 4 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Ted DiBiase Jr (2) | 2 Events | 1 Match Type | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Tensai (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Texas Tornado (2) | 2 Events | 2 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️The Great Khali (12) | 12 Events | 8 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 4 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️The Miz (5) | 5 Events | 2 Match Types | | 2 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️The Rock (7) | 7 Events | 5 Match Types | | 3 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Tito Santana (11) | 11 Events | 5 Match Types | | 3 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | 1 Elimination |
| ➡️Tommy (20) | 20 Events | 10 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 5 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Triple H (49) | 49 Events | 19 Match Types | 4 Shared Teams | 15 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | 1 Elimination |
| ➡️Tyler Breeze (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Typhoon (2) | 2 Events | 2 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️Tyson Kidd (5) | 5 Events | 4 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️Ultimate Warrior (10) | 10 Events | 3 Match Types | 2 Shared Teams | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | 1 Elimination |
| ➡️Undertaker (39) | 39 Events | 13 Match Types | 3 Shared Teams | 13 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | 1 Elimination |
| ➡️Val Venis (5) | 5 Events | 2 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Vex (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Vince McMahon (4) | 4 Events | 3 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Virgil (7) | 7 Events | 2 Match Types | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Viscera (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | 1 Defeat by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Vito (14) | 14 Events | 9 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 4 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | 1 Elimination | |
| ➡️Wade Barrett (2) | 2 Events | 2 Match Types | | | | |
| ➡️Warlord (13) | 13 Events | 4 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | 3 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️William Regal (6) | 6 Events | 4 Match Types | | 2 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️X-Pac (3) | 3 Events | 2 Match Types | 1 Shared Team | | | |
| ➡️Xavier Woods (1) | 1 Event | 1 Match Type | | | | |
| ➡️Yokozuna (7) | 7 Events | 4 Match Types | | 2 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |
| ➡️Zack (10) | 10 Events | 5 Match Types | | 4 Defeats by Shawn Michaels | | |